
Crosby, Stills & Nash (Rhino High Fidelity Edition) (Rhino/Atlantic)
My original, 1969 copy, got its butt kicked
Rhino Records continues to mine the very rich, Warner archives, reissuing classic vinyl albums in their Rhino High Fidelity series, featuring meticulous detail throughout the entire creation process. This means 180-gram vinyl, improved fidelity, heavy-grade jackets, and extra booklets with liner notes.
I put my original, 1969-issued Atlantic Records’ version (complete with the linen fabric sleeve) up against this brand-new edition – and the results are stunning. It’s such a drastic improvement, you don’t have to be an audiophile to hear the difference.
First thing I noticed when I put the headphones on, is that the original vinyl of this album has WAY too much bass. Stephen Stills played most of the instruments on this debut, and he approached the bass like a guitarist, playing all over the neck. Problem is, the bass often overpowers all the other instruments and vocals, drowning everything else out.
On the opening cut, “Suite: Judy Blue Eyes,” I’m shocked at how brittle the guitars sound on my original. And, it’s way too bass-heavy. The difference in this new pressing is night and day: the acoustic guitars are crisp, but not shrill – you can discern Stills’ intricate harmonic work. The cymbals don’t roll off like they do in the 1969 edition. And, when the song builds to the climactic end, the harmonies are warm, not brutal.
For “Guinnevere,” the acoustic guitars are warmer in this new edition. And, I can hear a slight rhythm track in the left channel – like light brushes or something – never heard that before! On “You Don’t Have to Cry,” originally the bass bled over everything. By pulling that back, the track breathes more – you really hear the guitars.
One of the biggest differences comes with “Pre Road Downs” – as with so many songs near the end of an album side, their fidelity was limited back in the day. In this case, Graham Nash’s voice rolled off on the 1969 LP, especially when he screamed near the end. In this new case? So much better. No vocal roll off, and the instruments are warmer. Wow.
Side two opens with “Wooden Ships.” On the original copy, the instruments were too bright, while the High Fidelity one evens things out. Nash’s vocals are so close, you feel like he’s in the room with you on “Lady of the Island.” Then, David Crosby comes in with his counter vocal melody and it’s just gorgeous. Stills’ guitar is warmer here on “Helplessly Hoping,” and when those glorious, three-part harmonies hit you in stereo – it’s quite a rush!
“Long Time Gone” has always suffered from overpowering bass. So much so that the drums roll off because everything else is fighting for a chance to be heard. On this new edition, the bass is still pretty loud, but the drums have room to breathe, and so does the organ.
The album closes with “49 Bye Byes,” and yet again, there’s a huge improvement in the last cut on the side. The instruments in the High Fidelity version have a deeper quality, with Stills’ vocals more present. Right at the end of my copy, when they sing “cat’s eyes,” it distorts from too much high end. On the new version, it’s been smoothed out.
The Rhino High Fidelity edition of the debut from Crosby, Stills & Nash is the best one yet. It’s the biggest sonic improvement I’ve heard in any of this series. And, it proves that, when done right, vinyl can still sound fantastic in 2026. Absolutely worth every penny. —Tony Peters











