Beatles – Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (1967) – CD review –
So much has been written about this album that it can be difficult to separate historical significance from the actual music. Upon its release, Sgt. Pepper sent shockwaves through the music industry. It stretched the boundaries of what was acceptable in pop music and it also introduced many elements of studio trickery that were equally unique. However, over 40 years later, what really matters is the music, and frankly, this is not the best the Beatles had to offer.
This isn’t their best album by far; it probably isn’t even in the top five (I would put Rubber Soul, Revolver, Abbey Road, Help and Beatles For Sale all ahead of this one). There are several songs here that simply aren’t that good, like “Lovely Rita,” “Good Morning Good Morning,” “Being For the Benefit of Mr. Kite,” and “When I’m Sixty Four.” Then, there’s the George Harrison Indian flavored “Within You Without You” which is experimental, but listenable?
Not really. Only “Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds,” “Getting Better,”and “A Day in the Life” truly stand as spectacular moments. Greatness transcends time and circumstance. But, without the historical background, this album doesn’t really stand on its own. If you’re trying to explain the Beatles to someone who’s never heard their music, start with Beatles 1. –Tony Peters